Herbstakademie Ascona 2006 (9.10.06/CB/Tsch)
ABSTRACTS (oral presentations)
THURSDAY, October 5th
Hermann HAKEN Stuttgart (D)
A Model of Cognitive Pattern
Formation Based on Synergetics
In this introductory lecture, I will
discuss dynamic systems theory and related approaches with respect to
their potentialities and limitations concerning cognition. Thus I
will address fields such as dynamic systems theory, bifurcation
theory, chaos theory, general system theory, synergetics, the theory
of stochastic processes and some more.
One may safely say that dynamic
systems theory originated from the mathematical treatment of the
motion of celestial bodies, in particular the motion of the planets
around the sun. Basically the motion, i.e. the dynamics, is described
by differential equations that determine the velocities and positions
of the individual bodies because of the forces exerted on them. The
equations are deterministic. The development of dynamic systems
theory includes both quantitative and qualitative approaches and
incorporates branches such as chaos theory and bifurcation theory.
Among the concepts are stability, instability, and attractors. This
approach ignores, however, the role of fluctuations that may be quite
important. In modern science, whenever a mathematical treatment of
systems whose states change in the course of time is asked for,
dynamic systems theory is taken into consideration.
The interdisciplinary field of
synergetics originated from laser physics. It is based on a
mathematical approach that, taking into account deterministic and
stochastic processes, deals quite generally with the formation and
functioning of structures, irrespective of the nature of the material
substrate and thus applies to a great variety of disciplines. The
methodology of synergetics allows us to unearth far-reaching
analogies between otherwise quite different systems.
Finally, I will discuss neural
network approaches. They are mainly based on comparatively simple
rules about the action of the individual elements (model neurons),
but because of the network character require computers. More
recently, analytical treatments were developed in particular for
studying effects of synchronization between groups of neurons.
Without going into the technical details of all these approaches I
will discuss their applicability to various aspects of cognitive
science, in particular to the problem of emergence.
Paul ZIOLO Liverpool (UK)
Catastrophe Theory Semantics
and the Principles of Embodied Cognition
The elementary catastrophes
and the transversality theorem they derive from point to a class of
deep structures inherent in the very space-time fabric of the
universe we inhabit and express the deepest principles of human
morphogenesis and embodiment. Rather than being static in the sense
of the Platonic forms, they are structurally stable dynamic flows,
which are capable, by virtue of their topologies and through mutual
embedding within one another, of very high variance.
Catastrophe Theory Semantics (CTS)
applies the principles of catastrophe theory to the study of language
emergence and cognition. The field was initiated by René Thom,
then developed during the 80's and 90's by Wolfgang Wildgen, Jean
Petitot, Franson Manjali and others, including thepresent author. CTS
investigates the pre-verbal affective and cognitive dynamics that
arise prior to the concretisation of a given utterance in everyday
speech or writing. This paper will briefly demonstrate the ways in
which catastrophe-derived structures, called archetypal
morphologies, are derived from trajectories through the
“canonical” manifolds, how these morphologies underlie
the case structures of different language families and how they
interconnect and become enfielded within one another in flows of
discourse. Examples will be drawn from everyday English, literature
and political propaganda.
These examples will show that in
revealing the continuities and discontinuities that underlie the
specific phoneme-combinations, concepts, sentences and syntax of
language production, CTS does not necessarily offer an
“alternative” mode of analysis to the more
“discretised” syntactic paradigms of Frege or Chomsky,
but rather supports and complements them, inviting us to consider
them as specific instantiations of a more general “naturalising
phenomenology” relating to human embodiment.
The power of CTS as a heuristic tool
is that in revealing both the psychodynamic and cognitive structures
underlying the flow of discourse, it is also independent of any
specific language. It therefore has a far wider range of
applicability than any mode of analysis tied to the more specific
syntactic framework of any single language group.
FRIDAY, October 6th
Rolf PFEIFER Zürich (CH)
How the Body Shapes the Way
we Think
The classical approach to
artificial intelligence, also called the cognitivistic approach,
views intelligence at the level of algorithms or computer programs.
Algorithms, by definition, do not have any interesting kinds of
dynamics. With the advent of embodiment the incorporation of
morphology, materials, control, and interaction with the environment
into a theory of intelligence the situation has changed
dramatically. If we are to build embodied agents we must understand
the interaction and tradeoffs between these aspects, which is the
essence of the "principle of ecological balance”, one of a
set of design principles for intelligent systems (see below).
Rather than focusing on the neural
substrate only, in the embodied approach the focus is on the complete
organism, which includes morphology (shape, distribution and physical
characteristics of sensors and actuators, limbs, etc.) and materials.
Often, given a particular task environment, if the morphology and the
materials are right, the amount of neural processing (or more
generally, control) required may be dramatically reduced. Stated
differently, we not only have to take the neural dynamics into
account but also the physical dynamics of the agent and how it
interacts with the neural one.
The synthetic methodology, i.e. the
methodology of "understanding by building”, which serves
to understand natural phenomena such as walking, perception, or
memory, proceeds by building physical systems, and then tries to
abstract general principles of intelligent behavior. In a number of
scientific disciplines biology, neuroscience, psychology, and
robotics there has lately been a surge of interest in human
development, from infants to adults. In developmental robotics, where
robots are employed to elucidate developmental processes, robots
interact with their environments over extended periods of time,
mimicking a developmental process, which enables the robot to acquire
its own "personal history”. In contrast to humans, this
"personal history” can be completely recorded into time
series files and subjected to statistical and information theoretic
analyses. This opens up entirely novel possibilities for cognitive
science and
provides, for example, the basis for studying the so-called
"symbol grounding problem”, how symbols come to be used to
convey meaning. It turns out that the ability to move and interact
with the real world is an essential enabler of meaning
acquisition.
In the presentation, I will introduce
a number of abstract principles that characterize intelligent
embodied systems, i.e. the principle of "cheap design”,
the principle of "sensory-motor coordination”, and the
principle of "ecological balance”. They will be
illustrated with examples from our own research and from work by
other research laboratories. I will speculate about how embodied
artificial intelligence might contribute to a dynamical theory of
cognition and outline a few issues that I consider essential for
future research.
Susanne VROBEL Kassel (D)
Simultaneity and
Contextualization: The Now's Fractal Event Horizon
The query as to how the mind
may interact with its context begs the further question "What is
the boundary connecting the mind and its context?". We generate
reality by distinguishing between self and non-self. The interfacial
cut between self and non-self produces a boundary, which should not
be imagined as a mere line, but rather as an intersection.
The interface between the observer
participant and the rest of the world is the Now, the event horizon
within which simultaneity may be generated. The Now is a temporal
natural constraint, which must be assumed to be extended and to
display a nested structure. The nested structure of the Now results
from the superposition of simultaneous levels of description
generated by the observer participant, which renders possible the
anticipation of simultaneous impacts from the outside world.
The extension of the world-observer
interface grows with each new embedding performance, i.e., each
successful contextualization. Total congruence between inside and
outside simultaneity would result in sheer simultaneity. This would
entail a loss of self, as the boundary between self and non-self
would cease to exist as a boundary: The boundary would host both self
and non-self.
The question as to how simultaneity
may be generated is exemplified by conditioning experiments and our
perception of multi-layered signals. Wider implications such as the
question as to whether there is a healthy boundary extension are
discussed within the context of local and global processing. As
global states both arise from and constrain local ones, the only
meeting point, the Now, both generates and is subjected to embedding
levels of description. Achieving and maintaining a healthy boundary
extension remains a perpetual balancing act.
Karl GRAMMER Vienna (A)
Embodied Communication in
Humans and Machines
Research in human
communication on an ethological basis is almost obsolete. The reasons
for this are manifold and lie partially in methodological problems
connected to the observation and description of behavior, as well as
the nature of human behavior itself. In this talk, we present a new,
non-intrusive, technical approach to the analysis of human non-verbal
behavior, which could help to solve the problem of categorization
that plagues the traditional approaches. We utilize evolutionary
theory to propose a new theory-driven methodological approach to the
"multi-unit multi-channel modulation” problem of human
nonverbal communication. Within this concept, communication is seen
as context- dependent (the meaning of a signal is adapted to the
situation), as a multichannel and a multi-unit process (a string of
many events interrelated in "communicative” space and
time), and as related to the function it serves. Such an approach can
be utilized
to successfully bridge the gap between evolutionary psychological
research, which focuses on social cognition adaptations, and human
ethology, which describes every day behavior in an objective,
systematic way.
Steven BOKER Notre Dame (USA)
Embodiment of Self and Other:
Mutual Regulation of Affective Symmetry in Conversation
In conversation, head nods,
gestures, postural adjustments, and facial expressions have
frequently been reported to exhibit coordination. One way to think
about this coordination is in terms of spatio-temporal symmetry
formation and attendant symmetry breaking. In this view, mirroring in
conversation is part of a dynamic process that regulates
interpersonal coordination. A recent theory to account for mirroring
involves so-called mirror neurons; neural structures that are
responsive both to actions of oneself as well as visually perceived
actions of others. fMRI evidence has implicated these mirror neuron
structures in language perception. Affect can be perceived through
the nonverbal actions that exhibit symmetry formation and symmetry
breaking in conversation. One possible conclusion is that during
conversation we embody our own affect as well as the perceived affect
of others in order to communicate and attain mutual understanding of
each other’s inner a
ffective states. This talk reports results of an experiment in which
motion of body and head position is tracked synchronously with facial
expression for pairs of individuals conversing over a closed circuit
television link. We interpret these results in the framework of
dynamic regulation of mutual affect through the embodiment of self
and others.
Hermann HAKEN and Juval
PORTUGALI Stuttgart / Tel Aviv (D / ISR)
The Relations between
Shannonian and Semantic Information and their Implication to
Cognition and Embodiment
Shannon’s information
theory defines information as a pure quantity irrespective of its
meaning. This is the theory’s basic property and achievement.
Since its introduction, the theory was applied to a variety of
domains ranging from engineering to biology, brain sciences and
cognition. In some of these applications the theory’s basic
property was indeed retained, but in others it was not. In the
latter, semantics entered in disguise, usually implicitly. In this
paper we first explicate the semantic component of such applications
and examine their implications. We then suggest a distinction between
two forms of Shannonian information with and without meaning.
Next, we explore how semantic information is created. We do so by
reference to the processes of pattern recognition and categorization.
Finally we discuss some theoretical and practical implications.
Gerhard LUHN Dresden (D)
Framework for a Triadic
Information Concept
„Das Selbe aber ist
Sein und Denken.“ „For the same thing is for thinking and
for being.” .Parmenides
Although Parmenides’ poem
is only very fragmentarily known, it shows that he is arguing against
a common spirit of the age. It was thought, that everything is just
changing and moving, without any more or less conceptual background.
But swimming against the stream costs energy. The work of Noam
Chomsky is another example for such an approach. The credo of such a
spirit is a doing, in order to create new opportunities, build
new causality chains. But it seems that this doing needs an
elaborated concept of word, of language. Such language
or similar structural activation networks has to ensure the
concept of multiple connectivity of prior unconnected information,
and though creation of new informational classes. I will argue that
the physical concept of such connectivity is created by non-local
system characteristics. The Neapolitan philosopher Giambattista Vico
has already discovered such non-local conception of language. He sta
yed that prior to any sentence, to any propositional statement, is a
phantasm. He called this capability of creating phantasms the
“universale fantastico”. So, if we learn something
new, this new concept will emerge to a new regularity; and will
establish a causal, lawful status. In consequence we create new
opportunities for our actions, and though freedom. Such new
conceptual regularity stands in between the change of a system, or of
communicating systems. The shape of a system is information. The
triadic information concept is though based on the conceptual
possibility of change. This includes the change of a single
system as well as the change of communicating systems.
While C.S. Peirce has already
introduced such a triadic semantics, information science is still
searching for a successor of Claude Shannons dyadic, probabilistic
information concept. Recently the physicist Hans Grassmann has done a
proposal for such a non-probabilistic information concept (Grassmann
2002). He is arguing that information storage is consuming physical
work, while pure information processing does not consume physical
work. Such information processing deals only with the transformation
of an input vector to an output vector. Only the creation and storage
of new information is characterized through dissipation of energy.
This will lead automatically to new structured order, and though to a
triadic concept (sender, receiver and lawful regularity between
those). The system of order will increase, if such new order
corresponds to “reality”. It may also decrease, if
unexpected surrounding conditions are changing.
But this formal concept of triadic
information appears also in our heads, and is based on non-formalized
thinking. Carl Friedrich von Weizsäcker has characterized this
circle, but comes to the conclusion, that this circle is in effect
needed to sharpen our thinking and acting. This means, that the
triadic information concept is based on a homomorph epistemological
approach. While for example evolutionary epistemology is arguing for
an isomorphic relationship between knowledge and reality, this can
not be justified from a position, which is based on the acceptance of
non-formalized thinking and the unpredictable appearance of implicit
knowledge. Where does the information in the universe comes from, how
can knowledge emerge from such information? How can lawful
regularities appear in nature and though in our thinking? How can a
triadic information concept, - a “continuous interconnected
thinking” of information and the lawful regularities based on
such inf
ormation add value to our work?
SATURDAY, October 7th
Thomas METZINGER Mainz (D)
1E, 2E, 3E, the PSM and the
PMIR: Three Kinds of Embodiment, the Phenomenal Self, and the
First-Person Perspective
I will first introduce three
different notions of embodiment, first-order embodiment (1E),
second-order embodiment (2E), and third-order embodiment (3E) in
order to counteract the semantic vagueness the term has acquired in
recent debates. Then I will sketch a strategy of accommodating the
perspectivalness of consciousness within an empirically plausible
theory of mental representation. An important step in adopting this
strategy will consist in introducing a new theoretical entity: The
phenomenal self-model. The model of the self differs from
every other mental model in an essential point. It possesses a part,
which is exclusively based on internally generated input: the part of
the body image activated by proprioceptive input. For instance,
recent research concerning the pain experienced in phantom limbs
seems to point tothe existence of a genetically determined
neuromatrix whose activation patterns could be the basis of the body
image and the subjectiv
e experience of embodiment. The part of this neural activation
pattern, which is independent of external input, produces a
continuous representational basis for the body model of the self and
in this way anchors it in the brain by generating a persistent
functional link. In almost all situations when there is phenomenal
consciousness at all, there also exists this unspecific, internal
source of input. It is the most "certain" and stable region
within the model of the self. In this way our consciousness becomes a
centered consciousness.
However, in order for the
functional/representational property of centeredness to become the
phenomenal property of perspectivalness, the model of the system must
become a phenomenal self. The pivotal question is: How does
that which we commonly call the phenomenal first-person perspective
emerge in a centered representational space? A conscious self emerges
if the system no longer recognizes the model of the self which it
itself activated as a model. If it did, representational and
functional centeredness would remain, but the global phenomenal
properties of selfhood and perspectivalness would disappear. In
short: the system would have a self-model, but no phenomenal
self. The representational correlate - the self-model - is a
functional module, episodically activated by the system in order to
regulate its interaction with the environment. One can also develop a
"teleofunctionalist" approach: The model of the system then
appears as a kind o
f organ which emerges through the binding of a certain set of
micro-functional properties and enables the system to represent
itself in its environment to itself. So the self-model is a transient
computational module, possessing a long biological history: It is a
weapon, which was developed in the course of a "cognitive
arms-race" (Andy Clark, 1989). A real phenomenal self however,
only emerges if the system, metaphorically speaking,
"confuses" itself with the internal model of itself which
it itself has generated. I claim that the activation of a transparent
self-model is the most important necessary (but not sufficient)
condition for the instantiation of what philosophers like to call the
"first-person perspective": While activating a special type
of representational object, the system gets caught in a
naive-realistic self-misunderstanding and in this way generates a
phenomenal subject. If time allows, I want to close by briefly
investigating
what further constraints have to be met in order for a phenomenal
first-person perspective to lay the foundations for social cognition:
How do we get from a consciously represented first-person perspective
to the cognitive representation of a first-person plural
perspective?
References: For readers
interested in an English summary of the theory sketched above I
recommend the following two publications:
Metzinger, T. (2005).
Précis of „Being No One“. In PSYCHE
An Interdisciplinary Journal of Research on
Consciousness, 11 (5), 1-35.
http://psyche.cs.monash.edu.au/symposia/metzinger/precis.pdf.
Metzinger, T. (2003). Being No One
- The Self-Model Theory of Subjectivity. Cambridge, MA: MIT
Press.
Andreas ALTORFER Bern (CH)
Adaptive Systems of Head
Movement Activity in Everyday Life Appearance, Characteristic,
Behavioural Relation and Meaning
Head movement patterns are
embedded in behavioural performance of everyday life. Their
presentation depends on multiple biological and psychological factors
that take part in specific situations. Research interest in head
movement behaviour can be found in social interaction (including
verbal and nonverbal communication), psychomotor activity, and goal
oriented behaviour. While head movement behaviour is usually rated,
there is little knowledge about the dynamic emergence of movement
patterns over time. Moreover, movement behaviour is described using
predefined categories that reduce the presented complex variability
to observable units in time and space. In contrast, applying a direct
measurement of head movement patterns, results concerning 4 different
domains are presented: 1. The detection of head movement patterns
relevant for the course of interaction during conversation
especially occurring in situations of emotional stress, 2. The
presentation of h
ead movement behaviour in situations established through different
experimental tasks, 3. The impact of biological manipulation on
behavioural presentation of head movement patterns and activity, and
4. The specific role of head movements during goal oriented behaviour
especially investigated during coordinated movements of eye
and head. An evaluation of the head movement dynamic is done by an
application of the situational information in combination with
quantified head movement patterns. Thereby, relevant head movement
patterns are detected using empirical evidence; a three-dimensional
quantification of head movements is related to environmental data to
show their dynamic variation. In this respect emblematic aspects of
head movement patterns are described.
Günter SCHIEPEK and
Igor TOMINSCHEK Bamberg (D)
The Embodiment of Cognitive
and Emotional Phase-Transitions in the Brain
The brain is one of the most
complex nonlinear dynamic systems we know, working at the "edge
of chaos" (as W. Freeman quotes it). So we can suppose that
nonlinear phase-transitions are common phenomena in neural networks,
taking place at different time scales. The question is how the brain
represents instability (or stability) and how these neural activity
patterns correspond to mental and behavioural phase transitions. Two
examples - one in the field of motor behaviour, using the well known
Haken-Kelso finger movement paradigm, and the other in the field of
psychotherapy processes - will be used to approach to some answers.
The psychotherapy study uses repeated fMRI measures corresponding to
stable or instable periods in the subjective experience of patients
with obsessive-compulsive disorders. The data are sampled by daily
subjective self-ratings using pocket-PDAs.
Zeno KUPPER Bern (CH)
Body, Mind and Mindfulness
Traditional and Cognitive Psychotherapy Perspectives
Recent developments in
clinical psychology and psychotherapy have been influenced and
inspired by Buddhist mindfulness traditions. Specific interventions
for a wide variety of disorders such as psychosomatic disorders,
borderline personality disorders and depression incorporate elements
from mindfulness traditions. In these interventions, some form of
mindfulness meditation, as well as a corresponding view, stressing
awareness and acceptance are introduced. Randomized controlled trials
suggest that these mindfulness-inspired interventions are effective.
Interestingly, these developments seem to be more than a mere
incorporation of new therapeutic techniques. Aaron T. Beck, the
founder of cognitive psychotherapy, has summarized striking
similarities between concepts of cognitive psychotherapy and
traditional Buddhist psychology. For example, both approaches stress
the illusory (or irrational, dreamlike) nature of much of what human
beings ordinarily "think&qu ot;. Beck describes this as "egocentric biases leading to
excessive or inappropriate anger, envy, cravings, etc. … and
false beliefs." False beliefs span from a person with
depressions' conviction that he or she is the "a total
failure" to the common believe in the existence of a solid,
permanent "self". Both mindfulness traditions and cognitive
psychotherapy assume that such illusions or false beliefs are a basis
for mild and extreme forms of human suffering and present methods to
overcome false beliefs, as to develop a more open, realistic and
joyful approach to life. Common methods according to Beck include
(1) a focus on the immediate (here and now) (2) targeting
the biased thinking (3) he use of imagery (4) separating
distress from pain and (5) mindfulness training. The body,
somewhat neglected in cognitive psychotherapy, plays a crucial role
in mindfulness meditation. Elements of mindfulness meditation, such
as upright posture and awareness of the breath exemplify this. In
the mindfulness traditions, awareness of the body has been termed as
a "foundation of mindfulness" and the body has been
described as "the stabilizing element that brings mind to the
present" (Dzogchen Ponlop Rinpoche).
Fabian RAMSEYER Bern (CH)
Coordination of Nonverbal
Behavior in Psychotherapy: Synchrony as a Marker of Rapport?
Background. Previous
studies have conceptualized nonverbal coordination between client and
therapist as nonverbal components of the working alliance.
Our goal was to quantify the
level of coordination in dyadic psychotherapies in order to explore
behavioral synchrony and its interrelation with rapport.
Methods. Nonverbal analysis
focused on movement patterns of client and therapist during the
course of selected sessions. The raw data consisted of video
sequences recorded by two cameras. Data collection was accomplished
by motion energy analysis carried out by a fully automated
frame-by-frame examination of the video sequences resulting in basic
descriptors of each subject’s individual movement patterns.
Coordination was measured as the time delay between movements of the
interactants. Additionally, time series of the temporal flow of
motion energy were compared and signs of simultaneous and time-lagged
movements were being automatically detected. Various features thus
quantified synchronization of nonverbal activity between client and
therapist. These features were then related to post-session
evaluations of both client and therapist (session impact scores) and
other outcome measures.
Results. Findings showed that
in a sample of 48 highly successful -and unsuccessful therapy
sessions, the quality of the therapeutic bond was positively
correlated with the amount of synchrony for that session.
Additionally, global movement parameters revealed that turn-taking
was more prominent in sessions where therapists rating of
patients’ cooperation was high.
Discussion. This exploratory
analysis of selected therapy courses showed that the chosen
methodology was appropriate for the investigation of the role of
synchrony in psychotherapy sessions and its interrelation with
empathy.
Jörg TROJAN Mannheim (D)
Perceptual Somatotopic Maps
of the Body Surface
The representation of the
body surface in the primary somatosensory cortex can be measured with
a range of neuroimaging methods. The resulting spatial activation
patterns are often interpreted as if being iso- or at least homomorph
to perceptual patterns. This simplified view neglects the operational
differences between the mental construct of subjective space and the
physical space of the brain activations, whatever their ontological
status and/or relation.
In this paper, we present a
psychophysical approach to the parametrisation of subjective space:
Invisible CO2 laser stimuli were presented to the dorsal forearm and
direct position ratings were used to constitute somatotopic maps of
the perceived stimulus positions.
The laser stimuli could be localised
quite consistently but individually varying biases were present,
mostly leading to a “compressed” perceptual map compared
to the actual stimulus positions. Modulating the responses through
skin sensitisation with capsaicin resulted in increased distortions.
In addition, it could be demonstrated that spatiotemporal
interactions in the sub-second range (the saltation phenomenon,
Geldard & Sherrick, 1972) dynamically distort the perceptual maps
(Trojan et al., 2006).
Our method allows to parametrically
map the subjective space to the physical space of brain activations
and vice versa by calculating the relation between perceptual and
cerebral maps. Spatiotemporal “illusions” like saltation
are of special interest, as they involve specific, well-defined
distortions in the subjective space, which most likely relate to
particular cerebral activation patterns. First attempts to measure
(Blankenburg et al., 2006) and model (Wiemer et al., 1995) such
underlying neural integration mechanisms have been made, but need
further refinement.
Nathalie POEPEL Osnabrück (D)
From Body to Action: Body
Sensing as a Tool for Overcoming Procrastination
To enact an intention,
people need to generate energy to do so. According to the concept of
action and state orientation (Kuhl, 2001), people differ in their
ability to self-generate this energy. State oriented people (SOP)
tend to behaviour inhibition, procrastination, reduced wellbeing and
increased left hemispheric activation, but only in demanding
situations. On the contrary, action oriented people (AOP) show
increased performance skills and wellbeing under the same
conditions.
It is hypothesized that body sensing
(perceiving bodily sensations and changing them) helps SOPs to
overcome inhibition. It is assumed that sensing ones body leads to an
increase in right hemispheric processing and as a result of this to
an activation of the self-system. According to Kuhl´s
Person-System-Interaction-Theory (PSI-Theory), the self supports the
generation of enactment energy and thus increases reaction speed.
This idea was empirically examined in a series of simple reaction
time experiments. Body sensing interventions were compared to
cognitive rumination, cognitive distraction and neutral conditions.
Results support the basic assumption: SOPs in cognitive load
conditions were significantly slower than AOPs, but gained in
reaction speed (up to 60 msec) under body sensing conditions and thus
performed as good as AOPs. Furthermore, emotional wellbeing only
improved after body sensing but not after cognitive interventions.
Implications of these findings f
or further studies and psychotherapy will be discussed.
Benita CANTIENI Zürich (CH)
CANTIENICA ® - Method for
Bodyshape and Posture.
Cognition of the physical
Embodiment through Awareness
Thesis. Bodily posture highly
influences Emotion and Cognition. Bodily posture without cognitive
awareness is mainly a consequence of imitation from the social
environment, from imitation of social role models (i.e. parents,
friends, teachers, cultural role models), of frozen-in Emotions in
the body (i.e. stress, fear, resignation, shyness), and of anatomical
misconcepts.
Argumentation. Bodily posture
is a result, not a condition. Within the limits of one’s innate
nature the posture can be changed as long as we live. Postural
deformities can be adjusted through alterations in the posture and in
postural movement. With the postural changes, the emotional
embodiment changes, too. Examples can and have been made visible
through a test series with Infrared Thermography.
Conclusion. Rearrangement of
posture through realignment of the skeletal bones and joints changes
the array of musculature, sinews, ligaments, and fasciae. Embraced by
the term „Basic Embodiment“ this concept of realignment
consists of easy to follow steps to erect the pelvis and the thorax,
straighten up the entire spine, and align all major joints. Through
this profound alignment all musculature gets consciously
interconnected, releasing the joints of the body of compression and
friction. This realignment enables the “basic emotional
state” to change into a spontaneous ability of response.
SUNDAY, October 8th
Rafael NUNEZ San Diego (USA)
Abstraction and the Embodied
Mind: The empirical Study of Spatial Construals of Time
Cognitive research on
metaphoric concepts of time has focused on differences between moving
Ego and moving time models, but even more basic is the contrast
between Ego- and temporal-reference-point models. Dynamic models
appear to be quasi-universal cross-culturally, as does the
generalization that in Ego-reference-point models, FUTURE IS IN FRONT
OF EGO and PAST IS IN BACK OF EGO. The Aymara language instead has a
major static model of time wherein FUTURE IS BEHIND EGO and PAST IS
IN FRONT OF EGO; linguistic and gestural data give strong
confirmation of this unusual culture-specific cognitive pattern.
Gestural data provide crucial information unavailable to purely
linguistic analysis, suggesting that when investigating conceptual
systems both forms of expression should be analyzed complementary.
Important issues in embodied cognition are raised: how fully shared
are bodily grounded motivations for universal cognitive patterns,
what makes a rare pattern emerge, a
nd what are the cultural entailments of such patterns?
Harald ATMANSPACHER and
Peter beim GRABEN Freiburg (D)
Contextual Emergence of
Mental States form Neurodynamics
The emergence of mental
states from neural states by partitioning the neural phasespace
isanalyzed in terms of symbolic dynamics. Well-defined mental states
provide contexts inducing a criterion of structural stability for the
neurodynamics that can be implemented by particular partitions called
generating partitions. The corresponding stability criterion is
applied to the discussion of neural correlates of consciousness. It
is shown that mutually compatible mental descriptions, topologically
equivalent to the neurodynamical description, emerge if the partition
of the neural phase space is generating. If this is not the case,
mental descriptions are incompatible or complementary.